People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Excellent everything. Service was attentive and friendly. We sat outside and were well served. I had a signature Old Fashioned and a Black Manhattan. Both were very good although I do prefer the OF without club soda. Anniversary dinner with three courses blew us away. I had broiled oyster sampler and my lovely bride had the app strudel. The oysters were mouth watering, fresh, and savory, delicious. My main course was the duck, perfectly cooked, crispy with great flavored wild rice. My wife's DIVER scallop special was cooked perfectly, succulent and delicious...among the best scallop dish of our lives. With four drinks and two desserts our check totalled about 200 plus tip. This was top shelf fare for top prices. We were completely satisfied and I strongly recommend this restaurant. ”
“ A group of us went for restaurant week. The bartender was great, fun and knowledgeable. The wait staff excellent. We all enjoyed what we ordered and will return. I took the photos after having some! ”
“ The Ship Lantern Inn has always been one of my favorite restaurants for a nice dinner out when I'm visiting the area. It's always busy, so make reservations well in advance. The steamed edamae dumplings, bacon wrapped shrimp, filet mignon and the linguine with clams received a thumbs up. ”
“ The Ship Lantern Inn on Route 9W in Milton, NY is a charming and welcoming establishment that feels like stepping back in time. The old world decor adds to the ambiance and creates a warm and inviting atmosphere that is perfect for a romantic dinner or a night out with friends. The standout dish of the night was the Caesar salad, which was made fresh tableside and was full of flavor. The scallop special with leeks was also excellent - the scallops were perfectly cooked and the leeks added a wonderful depth of flavor. The fresh bread served with a tasty tomato tapenade was a great addition to the meal. To top off the meal, we shared a delicious apple crisp for dessert. The staff was friendly and attentive throughout the meal, and our server made great recommendations for dishes and drinks. Overall, I highly recommend the Ship Lantern Inn for anyone looking for a charming and enjoyable dining experience. The fresh and flavorful dishes, attentive service, and old world charm all contribute to a wonderful night out. ”
“ We had my mother's 90th birthday luncheon at The Ship Lantern Inn this afternoon. Setting everything up with Matt- the room, the menu, the cake for our party of 14, was so easy, he was professional and detail oriented, which put my mind at ease having never been there before. The room was beautifully set up from the linens, candles and fresh flowers. The service was efficient and well timed, staff very friendly and helpful. The food was fantastic, with several picky eaters who really raved, especially about the baked clams, salmon and steak. The cake was lovely, perfect. Having had people in from California and the Carolinas, who haven't seen eachother in a while, we did linger a bit (it was hard to herd everyone out) but we didn't feel rushed. I appreciate that so much. It was a perfect afternoon. Looking forward to dining there again in the future. ”
“ My mother had been wanting to visit this quaint tiny location, and I was happy to bring her for Mothers Day which was such a nice treat for all involved. The food is truly seasoned and ingredients you can tell can tell carefully picked just as the staff. You must require that it! Factor to become a waiter here. Our waiter was phenomenal! The chef is incredible. The staff makes you extremely comfortable and catered to. The food is worth every penny. I believe for 4 people fhee bill was around 300 maybe a tad more this included 3 alcoholic beverages. Very delicious and I can't wait to visit again soon! ”
“ I wanted to surprise my wife by having her sister drive up from New Jersey and us drive down from Vermont so they could have a nice lunch together. So I looked for restaurants around have way. Found The Ship Lantern, checked it out, and I decided to try it. What a great choice service was great, food was better. I had the veal chop parmesean, which was perfectly cook and the portion was huge. I couldn't finish it all. That never happens me. It is a bit of a drive for us but we will be back. The Ship Lantern made a special day for my wife superb. Thanks to the staff!! ”
“ 6 out of 5 stars! This restaurant is insanely great. Professional wait staff and above expectation food and overall dining experience. Can’t recommend highly enough! Will travel from out of state hours just to come here again. Thank you for a wonderful experience. ”
Menu
Blue Point Oysters on Half Their Shell
US$18.50Hudson Valley Breast of Chicken Milanese
US$35.00Pan Roasted Parmesan Crusted Domestic Swordfish Steak
US$37.50Broiled Twin Imported Lobster Tails Drawn Butter
Filet of New England Sole Meuniere
US$36.50
About
Ship Lantern Inn
Welcome to the enchanting world of Ship Lantern Inn, located at 1725 Rte 9W in Milton, NY. This esteemed establishment invites you to indulge in an exquisite dining experience characterized by both modern flair and classic charm. Celebrated for its old-world decor and intimate ambiance, Ship Lantern Inn is a perfect setting for special occasions or casual gatherings with friends—especially as the sun sets against the picturesque Hudson Valley.
As you step inside, you are greeted by an atmosphere that whispers tales of culinary excellence. Ship Lantern Inn prides itself on offering a menu that celebrates the freshest ingredients and the art of fine dining. From the moment you peruse the offerings, the anticipation builds. Start with notable cold appetizers such as Blue Point Oysters served with a zesty Cajun cocktail sauce, or indulge in the delicious Ahi Tuna Tartare layered with Maryland crab and avocado, finished with a tantalizing Szechuan chile glaze and wasabi cream.
When it comes to the mains, the dishes are thoughtfully curated and rich in flavor. The Oven Roasted Fillet of Faroe Island Salmon glistens under a soy and Hudson Valley glaze, a dish that fuses Asian inspirations with locally-sourced ingredients. If you're craving seafood, the Porcini Dusted Fillet of Chilean Sea Bass paired with ginger-teriyaki glaze and lemon compound butter is an absolute must-try. Don't overlook the swordfish steak, a masterful creation that promises to delight.
Side dishes are not merely accompaniments here; they elevate your dining experience. Consider the Asparagus with Roasted Shallot Hollandaise or the Sauteed Hudson Valley Baby Spinach, both crafted to perfection, ensuring a well-rounded meal that excites the palate.
The rave reviews from patrons echo the sentiments of excellence, with customers praising the attentive service, intimate setting, and, most importantly, the food. One discerning diner reflected on a memorable anniversary dinner where fresh oysters and expertly cooked duck took center stage, while another lauded the Caesar salad made tableside—a testament to the restaurant's commitment to freshness and presentation.
It's no surprise that the Ship Lantern Inn has become a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike. The combination of friendly service, skillful culinary execution, and a charming atmosphere creates an experience that is hard to beat. Whether you are celebrating a momentous occasion or simply wish to treat yourself to a delightful meal, the Ship Lantern Inn guarantees a memorable experience that will have you returning time and again.
If you plan to visit, be sure to make a reservation. This gem has earned its reputation for good reason, so come hungry and ready to enjoy the best of what fine dining has to offer.
Book a table